Compare

ReplyHey vs the alternatives

The tools people weigh us against — one of them no longer with us — written the way we would want someone to write about us: what they do, what they do better, and who should pick them instead. Every claim was read off their own site, and the date we read it is on each page.

vs GummySearch

GummySearch closed on November 30, 2025. What it did, where each of its jobs lives now, and whether ReplyHey covers the half you actually used. Honest comparison.

vs F5Bot

F5Bot emails you every time a keyword appears on Reddit, Hacker News or Lobsters. ReplyHey scores the thread, checks the subreddit rules and drafts the reply. Honest comparison.

vs Subreddit Signals

Both find Reddit leads and draft replies without auto-posting. The difference is metering: ReplyHey caps no keywords, no subreddits and no leads on any plan. Honest comparison.

vs RedShip

RedShip caps websites, keywords and competitors per plan and has no free trial. ReplyHey caps no keywords at all, starts at $34.99 and sells unlimited websites for $99 flat, and gives you 2 days free. Honest comparison.

vs Bazzly

Bazzly can post and upvote for you from high-karma accounts. ReplyHey only ever posts from your own account, in your own browser, after you approve the draft. The honest comparison.

vs Octolens

Octolens is API-first social listening across 15+ platforms from $199/month. ReplyHey is Reddit-only leads with the reply drafted, at a founder price. Honest comparison.

vs Pulse for Reddit

Both score Reddit leads, draft replies and check subreddit rules without auto-posting. The differences: metering, seats, and what happens on the quiet days. Honest comparison.

vs Syften

Syften is fast, AI-filtered keyword alerts across Reddit, Hacker News, Slack groups and more. ReplyHey scores the thread and drafts the reply. Honest comparison.

vs Redreach

Redreach finds Reddit leads, guides replies and bulk-automates DMs. ReplyHey drafts both and automates neither send. Where the line sits, honestly compared.

vs Brand24

Brand24 is enterprise social listening from $249/month — sentiment, reports, every platform. ReplyHey is Reddit leads with the reply drafted. Honest comparison.

vs ReplyGuy

ReplyGuy auto-posts AI replies to Reddit from accounts it provides. ReplyHey drafts replies you post yourself. The difference is whose name is on the comment.

See which subreddits your customers are actually in

Paste your URL and ReplyHey derives the subreddits, the search terms and your first leads. About thirty seconds.

Find my first lead2 days free · $49.99/month after